Second of all- I LOVE musicals!
Third of all- I LOVE LOVE musicals!
Okay...onto the reviews:
1. Syesha- where have you been girl? Talk about personality, and WOW! I would SO see her in a Broadway show...and can I borrow her body and that dress for one day....PLEASE!!!! As my husband said, "Well, she's certainly not ugly." :)
2. Jason C- After they announced that he was going to sing "Memory" and went to commercial I said to Bill, "Oh no! This kid knows NOTHING about musicals and he picked Memory because it's so famous and of course it's like the only song he'll know and it's just going to stink." Ugh! Simon got it right- the longest 2 minutes!
3. Brooke- you're sweet but you need to go home. Your run is over. And I agree with Paula- you don't start and stop...not twice in one season and try to get away with it. I know she truly is a genuine person and I feel mean for saying this, but I'm done with the syrupy sweetness where everything is moving and touching and meaningful. I don't doubt she truly feels that way- I'm just over it. Am I mean for saying that?
4. David A- I guess I am eating my words from last week- that was truly amazing. Loved the version, loved the voice and the singing, still don't want you to win but-well done.
5. Carly- Thank you Sir Weber for making her change her song. What was with all the ballads huh? I LOVED Carly tonight- she was great, she was happy, she was smiling...and she cracked me up with that darn t-shirt! Can I buy that? You know it's going to be made into a real one within a week.
6. David Cook- I LOVED how he didn't try to change it and just showed another side to him. When he spoke in the beginning about how he grew up doing musical theater I was like, "Oh my goodness, just when I thought I couldn't like you and appreciate you more you say something like that!" He is so talented to do what he normally does week after week and then to stick to the original and just show off his vocals.....WOW. Can I preorder his album now?
So...David Cook "will always be my baby"...but nice job Carly, DAvid A and Syesha! Can every week be Andrew Llyod Weber week?
:)
M
5 comments:
I loved last night! Andrew Lloyd Webber was the most honest of the mentors. I have to admit, being older, I wasn't always fond of the rocker stuff of David Cook, but he is so well rounded he has won me over.
sub04
He is good...BUT, CARLY is the best.
I am officially done with AI this season. It is DEAD to me...
I know Carly wasn't going to win it, but for her to be in the bottom two and out and the dredlock loser fairy boy and Brooke to still be in it?? It is a travesty.
See ya next season AI....If I even want to watch...
Unbelievable. What are people thinking? Her best night yet and she goes.
I don't blame you, Bill.
DEAD..... IT IS OVER FOR ME...
MOSBY....OUT!
Post a Comment